Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

Al-Adahi v. Obama

February 12, 2009

MOHAMMAD AL-ADAHI, ET AL., PETITIONERS,
v.
BARACK H. OBAMA, ET AL., RESPONDENTS.
RAFIQ BIN BASHIR BIN JALLUL ALHAMI, ET AL., PETITIONERS,
v.
BARACK H. OBAMA, ET AL., RESPONDENTS.
FARHI SAEED BIN MOHAMMED, ET AL., PETITIONERS,
v.
BARACK H. OBAMA, ET AL., RESPONDENTS.
JIHAD DHIAB, ET AL., PETITIONERS,
v.
BARACK H. OBAMA, ET AL., RESPONDENTS.
HAMID AL RAZAK, ET AL., PETITIONERS,
v.
BARACK H. OBAMA, ET AL., RESPONDENTS.
ALLA ALI BIN ALI AHMED, ET AL., PETITIONERS,
v.
BARACK H. OBAMA, ET AL., RESPONDENTS.
MOHAMMED AHMED TAHER, ET AL., PETITIONERS,
v.
BARACK H. OBAMA, ET AL., RESPONDENTS.
MUHAMMAD AHMAD ABDALLAH AL ANSI, ET AL., PETITIONERS,
v.
BARACK H. OBAMA, ET AL., RESPONDENTS.



The opinion of the court was delivered by: Gladys Kessler United States District Judge

APPENDIX A

CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER #3*fn1

As indicated in the accompanying Memorandum Order, the Court includes here a revised version of Case Management Order #1. It integrates past clarifications and amendments.*fn2

I.

A. Factual Returns.*fn3 In accordance with Judge Hogan's Order of July 29, 2008, as amended by his Order of September 19, 2008, the Government shall file returns and proposed amended returns containing the factual basis upon which it is detaining Petitioner. See Hamdi v. Rumsfeld, 542 U.S. 507, 533 (2004) (holding that a "citizen-detainee seeking to challenge his classification as an enemy combatant must receive notice of the factual basis for his classification").

B. Legal Justification. The Government shall file a succinct (one or two paragraph) statement explaining the specific legal grounds upon which it relies for detaining Petitioner. If the Government's justification for detention is Petitioner's status as an enemy combatant, the Government shall provide the definition of enemy combatant on which it relies. If the Government has already filed a factual return, the legal justification is due within 14 days of the date of this Order. In all other cases, the Government shall include the legal justification with the factual return.

C. Unclassified Factual Returns. By January 9, 2009, the Government shall file an unclassified version of each factual return it has filed to date. In cases in which the Government has yet to file a factual return, the Government shall file an unclassified version of the return within 21 days of the date on which the Government is to file the factual return.

D. Exculpatory Evidence. 1. The Government shall disclose to Petitioner all reasonably available evidence

in its possession that tends materially to undermine the information presented to support the Government's justification for detaining Petitioner. See Boumediene, 128 S.Ct. at 2270 (holding that habeas court "must have the authority to admit and consider relevant exculpatory evidence that was not introduced during the [CSRT] proceeding"). The term "exculpatory evidence" includes any evidence of abusive treatment, torture, mental incapacity, or physical incapacity which could affect the credibility and/or reliability of evidence being offered. In this context, the term "reasonably available evidence" means evidence contained in any information reviewed by attorneys preparing factual returns for all detainees; it is not limited to evidence discovered by the attorneys preparing the factual return for the Petitioner. The term also includes any other evidence the Government discovers while litigating habeas corpus petitions filed by detainees at Guantanamo Bay. If the Government has already filed a factual return, disclosure of such exculpatory evidence shall occur within 21 days of the date of this Order. If the Government has not yet filed a factual return, disclosure of such exculpatory evidence shall occur within 21 days of the date on which it files the factual return. By the date on which disclosure is to occur under this paragraph, the Government shall notify Petitioner of the existence of any evidence within its actual knowledge but not within its possession or capable of being obtained through reasonable diligence that tends materially to undermine the information presented to support the Government's justification for detaining Petitioner. By the date on which disclosure is to occur under this paragraph, the Government shall file a notice certifying either that it has disclosed the exculpatory evidence or that it does not possess any exculpatory evidence.

2. If evidence described in the preceding paragraph becomes known to the Government after the date on which the Government is required to disclose exculpatory evidence in Petitioner's case, the Government shall provide the evidence to Petitioner as soon as practicable. The Government bears a continuing obligation to update and supplement the evidence described in the preceding paragraph.

E. Discovery. 1. If requested by Petitioner, the Government shall disclose to him: (1) any documents or objects in its possession that the Government relies on to justify detention; (2) all statements, in whatever form, made or adopted by Petitioner that the Government relies on to justify detention; and (3) information about the circumstances -- whether coercive or not -- in which such statements of that Petitioner were made or adopted. See Harris v. Nelson, 394 U.S. 286, 300 n.7 (1969) ("[D]istrict courts have power to require discovery when essential to render a habeas corpus proceeding effective."); Bismullah v. Gates, 501 F.3d 178, 187 (D.C. Cir. 2007) ("we presume counsel... has a 'need to know' all Government Information concerning his [or her] client...."), reh'g denied, 503 F.3d 137 (D.C. Cir. 2007), reh'g. denied en banc, 514 F.3d 1291 (D.C. Cir. 2008), cert. granted, vacated, Gates v. Bismullah, 128 S.Ct. 2960 (2008), reinstated, Case No. 06-1197 (D.C. Cir. Aug. 22, 2008) (per curiam), reh'g. granted in part, Case No. 06-1197 (D.C. Cir. Nov. 5, 2008) (per curiam) and deferred in part, Case No. 06-1197 (D.C. Cir. Nov. 5, 2008) (per curiam). If the Government has already filed a factual return, requested disclosure shall occur within 21 days of the date on which Petitioner requests the disclosure. If the Government has not yet filed a factual return, requested disclosure shall occur within 21 days of the date on which the Government files the factual return or within 21 days of the date on which Petitioner requests disclosure, whichever is later.

2. Petitioner may, for good cause, obtain limited discovery beyond that described in the preceding paragraph. Cf. Bracy v. Gramley, 520 U.S. 899, 904 (1997) ("A habeas petitioner, unlike the usual civil litigant in federal court, is not entitled to discovery as a matter of ordinary course."). Such discovery requests shall be presented by written motion and must: (1) be narrowly tailored, not open-ended; (2) specify the discovery sought; (3) explain why the request, if granted, is likely to produce evidence that demonstrates that Petitioner's detention is unlawful, see Harris, 394 U.S. at 300 ("[W]here specific allegations before the court show reason to believe that the petitioner may, if the facts are fully developed, be able to demonstrate that he is confined illegally and is therefore entitled to relief, it is the duty of the court to provide the necessary facilities and procedures for an adequate inquiry."); and (4) explain why the requested discovery will enable Petitioner to rebut the factual basis for his detention without unfairly disrupting or unduly burdening the Government. See Hamdi, 542 U.S. at 533 (holding that "a citizen-detainee seeking to challenge his classification as an enemy combatant must receive... a fair opportunity to rebut the Government's factual assertions before a neutral decisionmaker"); id. at 534 ("[E]nemy-combatant proceedings may be tailored to alleviate their uncommon potential to burden the Executive at a time of ongoing military conflict."). Any such motion for limited discovery must be filed no later than 14 days after completion of discovery pursuant to Section I. D and I. E of this Order.*fn4

F. Classified Information. If any information to be disclosed to Petitioner under Sections I.D. or I.E. of this Order is classified, the Government shall, unless granted an exception, provide Petitioner's counsel with the classified information, provided Petitioner's counsel is cleared to access such information. If the Government objects to providing Petitioner's counsel with the classified information, the Government shall move for an exception to disclosure. See Boumediene, 128 S.Ct. at 2276 ("[T]he Government has a legitimate interest in protecting sources and methods of intelligence gathering; and we expect that the District Court will use its discretion to accommodate this interest to the greatest extent possible."); CIA v. Sims, 471 U.S. 159, 175 (1985) ("The Government has a compelling interest in protecting... the secrecy of information important to our national security...." (citation omitted)). Petitioner's counsel may also move, on a case-by-case basis, to demonstrate why it is necessary to provide Petitioner with an adequate substitute for the classified information.

G. Traverse. In response to the Government's factual return, Petitioner shall file a traverse containing the relevant facts and evidence supporting the petition. See Boumediene, 128 S.Ct. at 2273 ("If a detainee can present reasonably available evidence demonstrating there is no basis for his continued detention, he must have the opportunity to present this evidence to a habeas corpus court."); cf. Hamdi, 542 U.S. at 533 (holding that a "citizen-detainee seeking to challenge his classification as an enemy combatant must receive... a fair opportunity to rebut the Government's factual assertions before a neutral decisionmaker."). Traverses are due within 14 days of the date on which the Government files notice relating to exculpatory evidence under ยง I. D.1 of ...


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.