Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

Elmer Campos-Alvarez and Marta Campos v. United States

April 7, 2011

ELMER CAMPOS-ALVAREZ AND MARTA CAMPOS, APPELLANTS,
v.
UNITED STATES, APPELLEE.



Appeals from the Superior Court of the District of Columbia (CF3-27538-06 & CF3-26583-07) (Hon. Robert I. Richter, Trial Judge)

The opinion of the court was delivered by: Glickman, Associate Judge:

Argued September 27, 2010

Before GLICKMAN and THOMPSON, Associate Judges, and SCHWELB, Senior Judge.

Appellants Elmer Campos-Alvarez and Marta Campos were tried together before a jury on charges arising out of a gang-related shooting. The jury found Elmer Campos-Alvarez guilty of assault with intent to kill while armed, aggravated assault while armed, three counts of assault with a dangerous weapon, and several related weapons offenses. It found Marta Campos guilty of obstruction of justice and conspiracy to obstruct justice. Although appellants raise several grounds for reversal, for the most part we affirm their convictions.

I. The Evidence at Trial*fn1

A. The Shooting

On the evening of August 5, 2002, Kenny Loza, his uncle Noel Loza, and his friend Javier Morales were attacked outside an apartment building in Northwest Washington, D.C. They were coming out of the building together when two men entered the driveway. At trial, Kenny Loza and Morales identified appellant Elmer Campos-Alvarez as one of the two men.

According to Kenny Loza, Campos-Alvarez confronted him, uttered a few angry words, pulled out a gun, and started shooting. Kenny was shot in the back and collapsed near where he had been standing. Noel Loza testified that Campos-Alvarez and his companion "shot directly at my nephew [Kenny] first, and then they shot at me as we were running." Noel managed to escape inside the apartment building, though he sustained gunshot wounds to his arm, knee, and hip. Javier Morales, who was standing somewhat apart from Kenny and Noel when the shooting began, also made it back inside the building, after first taking refuge behind a parked car and firing his own gun Other witnesses saw the shootings but could not identify the attackers. James Bryant was in the lobby of the apartment building when the gunfire erupted. He heard multiple gunshots and saw yellow flashes outside, which appeared to come from the driveway. Bryant was injured by glass fragments from the shattered front door. Jose Benitez also heard multiple gunshots as he and his daughter left the building and rushed back inside. Terrence Burnett was parking his jeep in front of the building when he heard the shots and saw sparks flying from the hands of two young men.

B. The Motive

Over defense objection, the government presented evidence at trial that the motive behind the assault on the Lozas and Javier Morales was gang-related. Kenny Loza and Morales were members of Vatos Locos, a Salvadorian gang. Appellant Campos-Alvarez belonged to Mara R (also called La Raza), a different Salvadorian gang. In the summer of 2002, Mara R was involved in a violent feud with Vatos Locos. Roque Lopez, a former Mara R gang member, testified at trial that Vatos Locos had "done a lot of shootings to us," and that Vatos Locos leader Oscar Chavez had killed a man named Walter Villatoro. Although Villatoro was not an actual member of Mara R, he had affiliated himself with that gang, and he was a friend of Campos-Alvarez.

According to Roque Lopez, Campos-Alvarez and his friend Jaime Alvarez visited him early in the evening on August 5, 2002. Campos-Alvarez invited Lopez and his acquaintance Jose Luca "to go take revenge from the V.L. people," and said he planned "to go shooting" at a nearby location where Vatos Locos members gathered. Lopez declined the invitation. He talked with Campos-Alvarez again some time after the shooting. Campos-Alvarez "told me that they went into the building where the V.L. people was [sic]," Lopez testified, "and that they saw the V.L. people, and they began shooting." Campos-Alvarez purportedly identified one of the Vatos Locos targets as Javier Morales and said that they shot at will and "didn't care who they g[o]t." Campos-Alvarez also asked Lopez whether Kenny Loza was alive or still in the hospital.

C. Attempts to Prevent Kenny Loza's Testimony

Campos-Alvarez was not arrested until 2006. His former girlfriend, Miradis Viera-Miranda, visited him while he was in the D.C. Jail awaiting trial. She testified that Campos-Alvarez asked her to offer Kenny Loza $5,000 to induce him not to appear in court. Campos-Alvarez renewed this request when Viera-Miranda visited him again in January 2007. He was angered when Viera-Miranda later told him that she "didn't want to get involved in nothing."

Appellant Marta Campos, Campos-Alvarez's sister, telephoned Viera-Miranda repeatedly to press her about contacting Kenny Loza. Campos left several voice mail messages for Viera-Miranda, who usually did not pick up the phone because she "didn't want to get involved." Sometimes Campos and Campos-Alvarez were on the call together to ask Viera-Miranda to help "them" out. On one occasion, Marta told Viera-Miranda that she and Campos-Alvarez were going to give her three thousand dollars "to get in contact with Kenny."

Viera-Miranda testified that in some of the phone calls, made between January and April 2007, Campos specifically asked her to "offer" Kenny Loza "money so he won't come to court." Kenny Loza confirmed at trial that Viera-Miranda informed him that Marta Campos "told her to call me to offer me money so I wouldn't come to court to testify against [Campos-Alvarez]." According to Viera-Miranda, Campos-Alvarez insisted to her "that he was innocent," and she professed to believe that the money was being offered to prevent an innocent man (Campos-Alvarez) from being convicted.

Marta Campos also approached Javier Morales's cousin, Melvin Morales, to obtain Kenny Loza's telephone number and address. Melvin's sister Elizabeth Morales overheard Campos tell him she "wanted to speak to Kenny to offer him money to not show up to court." Kenny Loza recalled talking with Elizabeth Morales about ...


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.